PDA

View Full Version : Judge Blocks Removal of Schiavo's Feeding Tube


Barbie
02-23-2005, 10:04 PM
Judge Blocks Removal of Schiavo's Feeding Tube (http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-022305schiavo_wr,0,7785360.story?coll=la-home-nation)

CLEARWATER, Fla. — A Florida judge today extended by 48 hours an order preventing the husband of a severely brain-damaged woman from removing a feeding tube that has kept her alive for the past 15 years.

Circuit Judge George Greer stayed removal of the feeding tube until 5 p.m. Friday to consider arguments made at a hearing by the parents of Theresa "Terri" Schiavo, who have waged a long legal battle to keep her alive.

Greer had previously ordered a stay until 5 p.m. today shortly after Florida's 2nd District Court of Appeal allowed expiration on Tuesday of a stay that had kept the feeding tube in place during the legal dispute.

Schiavo has been at the center of a court battle between her parents and her husband, Michael Schiavo, for seven years and the case has become a rallying point for right-to-life activists, advocates for the disabled and proponents of the right to die.

Some doctors say Terri Schiavo, 41, has been in a persistent vegetative state since suffering a heart attack that starved her brain of oxygen 15 years ago.

Michael Schiavo, who is her legal guardian, says his wife had told him she would not want to continue living in such a condition and he won court permission to remove the feeding tube.

His wife's parents, Robert and Mary Schindler, say their daughter could improve with treatment and have fought to keep her alive.

Attorney David Gibbs, who represents the Schindlers, said today, "This is clearly a life-or-death case. There is no need to rush."

Gibbs asked that the stay be extended so the court could consider the Schindlers' request to remove Michael Schiavo as their daughter's legal guardian and to conduct more neurological tests.

_______________________________________________________

I did a search of another thread where this was discussed...I couldn't find it.

She should live or should she die?

Mudflap
02-23-2005, 10:53 PM
If it were me, it would be well past time to die.

River Rat
02-23-2005, 11:18 PM
Me too

SimpleSimon
02-24-2005, 06:47 AM
Originally posted by Barbie:

I did a search of another thread where this was discussed...I couldn't find it.

She should live or should she die?

What do you think, and why?

In my opinion, the husband is undoubtedly a better judge of the mature opinions and desires of his wife than are her parents. Her life has been over for 15 years - the travesty forced upon her by the courts is not life, it is bodily existence only. Let her die.

Barbie
02-24-2005, 02:58 PM
What do you think, and why?

In my opinion, the husband is undoubtedly a better judge of the mature opinions and desires of his wife than are her parents. Her life has been over for 15 years - the travesty forced upon her by the courts is not life, it is bodily existence only. Let her die.

But she's alert and shows positive reaction when someone enters the room, as if she has recognition.

If you were her husband, could you do it?

SimpleSimon
02-24-2005, 10:00 PM
But she's alert and shows positive reaction when someone enters the room, as if she has recognition.

If you were her husband, could you do it?

One never knows the answer to such a question until confronted by the choice. As to her alertness and responsiveness, that is attested to by her parents only; not the attending medical personnel or her husband.

Barbie
02-24-2005, 10:03 PM
One never knows the answer to such a question until confronted by the choice. As to her alertness and responsiveness, that is attested to by her parents only; not the attending medical personnel or her husband.

From what I understand, her husband isn't even her husband anymore.

Has he not remarried.

Why doesn't he relenquish his responsibility of her, and let her parents take it all on...if that is what they all wish.

You're right though...'one never knows the answer to such a question, until confronted by the choice. ' :cry:

ms. bing
02-26-2005, 01:08 AM
there is one point that begs making.
this is a discussion about the removal of a feeding tube, not a life-support system. her heart and lungs apparently work on their own and will continue to do so for a while yet. she simply cannot feed herself or be fed.
to remove the feeding tube would not be a quick death. she would starve to death. slowly, painfully starve. i know i could not be party to that, and this is why this court case has been going on so long. unless they kevorkian'r up, which is not being discussed, this is not like pulling the plug. i might not want to live like that, but i hope and pray i am never unlucky enough to be in that position.
i'm reminded of a certain early metallica song....